Bach, Rachel. Honor's Knight. Orbit Books, 2014 (last week!). |
Honor's Knight: Or, the Rom-Act Grows a Conscience
The Meat
Recently I've been rather curmudgeonly about second
installments (in trilogies or longer series), pointing out that almost none manage to equal, and
astonishingly few surpass, the 'original' work from the first installment. How
many Empire Strikes Back-level sequels have there really been, after all? But as
various songs would have it, "This is it!" Rachel Bach (a.k.a. Rachel Aaron) charts a thrilling
ride for Devi Morris and the reader, bringing her and us several giant steps closer
to the clearly apocalyptic denouement looming just over the horizon (in book
three if not beyond). She's managed to improve on the already excellent foundations laid in
book one, ramping up both action and a sense of emotional engagement between characters
(and between the characters and the readers) to dizzying new heights.
Bach also delves deeper into the mechanics, so to speak, of the
various races and their physical (and more ethereal) attributes, treating the
reader to a fascinating and fully fleshed out rendering of their capabilities.
And she's also brought a new level of attention to the possibility of shifting
loyalties and alliances, even for Devi (who by her Paradoxian upbringing is a
bit of a samurai, "Death before dishonor or betrayal" kind of
loyalist). She finds new allies in the unlikeliest of figures, and friends turn
into enemies and then into the intermediate limbo of frenemies with
breathtaking speed. Yet Bach handles such situations with considerable care,
ensuring the reader can follow such rapid changes in alignments without any
difficulty accepting their plausibility.
In fact, Bach even raises the philosophical level of her
tale from relatively harmless rom-act (romantic action) in book one to a more
serious "At what price (individual/species/universe) survival?" It is
this greater level of nuance, more than anything, that humanizes both allies
and frenemies alike, because as readers we instinctively sympathize on an
emotional level with the romantics who insist some prices are too high to be
worth paying even as intellectually we are forced to concede the logic of the
utilitarians who insist that for the survival of the many, a few must be
sacrificed...in short, there are no Voldemorts or Dumbledores, no simple
paragons of good and evil, in this tale.
That said, Honor's
Knight never risks becoming too gloomy in tone or losing its (or, one might
imagine, Devi's own) irrepressible sense of optimism, that classical Hollywood-esque
feeling that everything not only might, it surely will turn out all right in
the end. Whether you approve of this sunny quality will depend, of course, on
whether you think the world is getting better or getting worse (let me just
say, for all you committed pessimists out there: what evidence can you possibly
have that the world is getting worse? And don't you dare say "because it's
more violent/dangerous," because invasion of the Ukraine notwithstanding,
humankind has never enjoyed such relative freedom from violence, on such a
(nearly total) global scale, in all of recorded history!) And speaking of
violence, Devi brings the goods: Honor's Knight contains plenty of good old
fashioned awesomeness in the form of Devi using her fancy armor to devastating
effect against a host of different enemies.
What isn't there to like about this sequel, in short? I can
only think of one thing, and that's the on again, off again romance between now
frenemies Devi and Rupert. Naturally we can all appreciate why a man would fall
for Devi—she's pretty amazing, after all—but why would she keep doting on this
guy (even leaving aside for a second the difficulty I have with the seriously
uncool name "Rupert") after all the crap he's put her through, and
more importantly, after she figures out his deal? Perhaps the title should be
"White Knight", because she's definitely got the syndrome, wanting to
save him from his own crappiness...
Be that as it may, however, Bach really delivered in this
volume, and she's got at least one reader who can't wait to read book three!
Will Devi uncover the mystery of the phantoms? Discover how to restore the
Daughters to themselves? Or just die in a blaze of (cool but ultimately
ineffectual) glory? Given the inexorability of a happy ending, something tells
me it won't be the latter!
The Math
Baseline assessment: 7/10
Bonuses: +1 for graying the story and characters up, and
rising above a Harry Potter-style simplistic view of good and evil... and +1
for doing so without losing the essential action-packed awesomeness at the
heart of book one
Penalties: -1 for still not quite selling the Devi-Rupert
"love conquers all" plotline
Nerd coefficient: 8/10 "Well worth your time and attention"
For more info on our scoring system--and thus, why an 8 is a fantastic score--see here!