The Meat
Apparently Max Allan Collins has been reading my dream
journal again. A crime novel set in the shady comic publishing world of the
fifties? Mobsters, beatniks, and two kinds of sexy nerds? Yes, I am interested.
Well, he didn’t get it exactly right: the love interest was
a blonde, not a brunette.
Seduction of Innocent
shares a certain quality with the paperback trash that it emulates: this is a
novel to be enjoyed, quickly and preferably thoughtlessly. This isn’t Crime and Punishment, but then again I
can’t ever get passed the old lady’s killing. So in that way Seduction of the Innocent is the exact
opposite of an important piece of literature: I actually read and genuinely
enjoyed it.
I don’t want to accuse Max Allan Collins of being a hack,
but he is a skilled and prodigious hack.
There are moments during which the book feels formulaic, many formulaic
moments. The characters are more or less stock -- the tough guy investigator,
the smart dame, Sal Mineo, the slutty dame -- and it reads at times like
Collins was getting paid per word. But none of this bothered me much. Seduction of the Innocent was…I don’t
know how to end this without using trite phrases like “page-turner,” “fun romp,”
or “highly readable.”
Seduction of the Innocent is marked by careful plotting, sharp
dialog, and a mastery of genre conventions -- even clichés and
well-worn tropes are expertly wielded. Though the characters are hardly original,
they’re engaging and appealing. Sometimes they're even funny.
But then there’s the book’s denouement. Seduction of the Innocent is more roman
de clef than roman noir. Though
my tastes tend toward the hardboiled, I can appreciate a good murder mystery.
Well, I have. But the mystery at the center of Seduction of the Innocent was not all that mysterious. I had it
figured 75 pages before the denouement -- and I’m not the most attentive reader.
Collins didn’t necessarily drop the ball. He simply used a rather contrived
scenario to unmask the book’s murderer -- which was in stark contrast to
Collins subtle manipulation of conventions throughout the novel.
Mention must be made of Terry Beatty's art. On it's own, it's good. As it's used in the book, it's good. I also just really like it when books have pictures.
Despite the criticisms leveled avove, I would recommend
Seduction of the Innocent to fans of
crime fiction, comic book history-lovers, and people who like to read books
that entertain. If this doesn’t sound like you, why are you visiting this site?
Oh...for the sci-fi.
The Math
Objective score: 6/10
Bonuses: +1 for the comic industry of the 50's; +1 for Terry Beatty's art; +1 for sexy nerds
Penalties: -1 for a disappointing ending; -1 for genre cliches (though they're used well)
Nerd Coefficient: 7/10
