Thursday, January 25, 2024

Seven Kennings Trilogy and the Power of Story

With the publication of the final volume of the Seven Kennings trilogy, we read back through the series and consider the three books as a whole.


At a book event Hearne did in Minnesota in early November, he remarked that before his popular Iron Druid series took off, the first book he wrote for submission was a prototype version of A Plague of Giants. While that book was on submission, for fun, he wrote Hounded, and so the Atticus stories took off. That early version of A Plague of Giants, he confessed, was ultimately not good--only the tiniest fraction of it made it into the new novel when he set to writing it.

But now that he has written the entire trilogy, what has he accomplished, and what was his ambition? His ambition, it is clear to me upon reading and completing this trilogy, is to have written an epic fantasy trilogy that at it’s heart is about how epic fantasy stories are told, and the consequences and power of telling that story.


A Plague of Giants begins with the following words:

"When we encounter a voice that moves us on an emotional level, by turns wringing tears from our eyes and plucking laughs from our bellies, there is an ineffable quality to its power: all we know is that we like listening to it and want to hear more."


Right at the start, we find that this novel, and this trilogy is about the telling of story. A bard with the power of a Kenning, in particular the magical ability to project his voice, begins to tell the war-weary city of the war that they themselves are suffering privation under.  We are in medias res of the Giant’s War, and the bard, we soon learn, has been sent to tell the story of the Giants War and prepare the populace for what is to come next.


But it’s not a simple linear narrative. This is not a simple recitation of facts. The bard has collected and (with his flawless memory) organized a raft of stories from, ultimately, twenty or so points of view. This sounds absolutely unwieldy and unsustainable and it is a high wire act that Hearne works at through the books. Hearne manages it by telling the stories of these characters through the bard in a narratively interesting and engaging order, which is not a straight up order by dates. And by having the bard tell the stories, we can use present day events in Pelemyn itself as a breather and a buffer from the stories he tells. 


What’s more, this ambitious three volume out of order narrative drives plot right up to the “present”, when Fintan the bard announces that, fifty days in, he has caught them all up. That is all well and good, but the way that Fintan has told his story, the order he has taken, has in itself frustrated and driven to action the bard’s putative partner, Dervan the historian, to actions himself in that aforementioned present day narrative. The ordering of the tales is itself a layer that drives some of the action itself. 


At the end of A Curse of Krakens, Hearne gives his game away. He gives a complete order of all the events in the three books by date and reference to the “Day” Fintan tells the story or incident, and it really shows just how much of a high wire act that Hearne has been doing across three volumes in order to tell the story in the order that gives the most narrative impact. Even if, as he is driven to action, Dervan is frustrated by the out of chronological order of events that are spun out of the bard and says so. 


So the three novels are in a dialogue with history (and having the present day MCs (until the actual war fleet and strike back against the Giants) be a storytelling bard and a historian is an incredibly interesting and rich choice by Hearne. The three novels as a throughline in the present allows the author to explore the differences, the important differences between telling and ordering events for a history (which Dervan has been commissioned to write) versus the ordering of events and narratives and stories of people to tell an epic fantasy story. 


I am reminded of a favorite quote of mine from the author Roberto Calasso, who wrote a ouroboros sort of mythological book in The Marriage of Cadmus and Harmony:


Stories never live alone; They are the branches of a family that we have to trace back, and forward.”


The choices in transitions and when to break off from a character are disguised as Fintan wanting to tell different stories to different days to a populace suffering deprivation, and seeking distraction by any means. That is the Holmesian version of why he switches characters when he does in the narrative (usually two or three characters get a POV in a particular “day”) But in the Doyleist view. The reason why Hearne does it is to give the story tension, to add suspense and mystery. It frustrates Dervan and I think, too, in a Doyleist vein, it is a tip of the cap from Hearne to the reader as to why we have to break and the order that things are told, time and again, Dervan, as our primary POV in the present, shows his own frustration and reactions whenever things break.  As an example, in A Blight of Blackwings, when Gondel Vedd makes a stunning discovery and makes a resolution that clearly was not fulfilled, but then, to show a thematic change rather than following up immediately, the bard switches to Abbinava. 



Part of all of this narrative switching and telling tales and trying to untangle them is the theme of espionage that goes through most of the volumes. From the get go, although his help is appreciated, Fintan is seen by the government of Pelemyn as a possible spy, and Dervan is recruited to, while overtly, to write down the bard’s tales as history, but really to be a spy (much to his own chagrin, he protests throughout the series that he is not a spy and does not want to be).  That tension is ramped up when we start to learn, as the series progresses, is that the Bone Giants have spies in the various kingdoms, and baffling their intelligence gathering and untangling those networks, becomes an important plot both in the stories Fintan tells as well as our reluctant spy, Dervan, who winds up getting caught by same. 


Readers of NOAF may recall that Hearne’s book is not the only book this year that deals with the power and narrative power, and importance, and implications of story. R.R Virdi’s The First Binding, first in a series [my review here] , has a storyteller protagonist, and the narrative unfolds in a present that is broken by long passages showing us the storyteller’s past, but those past events are told in such a way and manner as to reflect and look upon the present. Virdi has ambition equal to Hearne’s in that he is investigating narrative in a way that, in its way, is deeper than Hearne in looking at the narrativeology of stories in a somewhat more structured and deliberate manner. Virdi does use this instead of a raft of points of view and so we get a more focused epic story  But Virdi’s use of a magic-infused storyteller and Hearne’s use of a magic-infused storyteller shows readers that sure, fighters, mages and even clerics can be cool, but so can bards. Don’t count out the power of a bard. 


I want to talk about formats, and their reading experience, and this goes again to something that Hearne said in the aforementioned event in Minnesota. He said that his sales of print and ebooks were decreasing over time, but his audio sales were not only strong, but actively growing. He gave all credit for this to one of his narrators, Luke Daniels (the other for the Seven Kennings trilogy is Xe Sands). I consumed these books in both ebook and audio form and tried to switch back and forth between the audible app and the ebook. This only worked sporadically according to plan and sometimes I needed to forward one to catch up with the other, and other times it seemed to pick up the change and offered the update.  


I have mixed feelings about the three potential formats here, there are strengths to the print that the ebook mitigates, somewhat, and the audiobook has, but the reverse applies as well. Hearne, in addition to writing, also did the entrancing maps of the series, showing an eye for cartography as well as writing. These come across best in the hardcovers, less well in the paperbacks, even more frustrating in the ebooks, and of course do not exist in the audiobook at all, really, aside from the “accompanying PDFs” (which in the end are even more inconvenient than the ebook in looking at the maps and other associated matter). 


So while this consideration alone might drive one toward the print books, there is a reason to consider the reverse. This is a story which is mostly narrated by a bard. This is a story, a work that, to my reading and opinion, hits its cylinders best when Fintan is telling the stories of twenty characters.  (I feel the last portion of the story, which are diary and journal entries of the expedition, is somewhat weaker because of the huge strength of Fintan as narrator). And hearing Daniels and Xands voice the characters as Fintan is doing so is an experience that at points is positively revelatory. They understand the material, they love the material and that appreciation comes through. I think, then, that for its disadvantages as noted above, the audiobooks are, for me, the definitive version of these epic tales.


In the end, Hearne, in three volumes, has laid a marker down on using the long form epic fantasy trilogy to explore the nature of story, how they are told, who tells those stories and what that all means. There is a joy and power to stories, that is made clear right on the first page of the trilogy, as a bard is sent to a city under deprivation, to tell stories to inform, and distract an audience that has already been through a lot, and more sacrifice is yet required. Stories inform us, educate us, enlighten us, lift us up, and ultimately, give us hope. There is much else to unpack in this series, so much that Hearne has to say, but for the reader or potential reader, I urge you: quaerendo invenietis: Seek and you shall discover.


--


References:

Hearne, Kevin, A Plague of Giants, [Del Rey, 2017]

Hearne, Kevin, A Blight of Blackwings, [Del Rey, 2020]

Hearne, Kevin, A Curse of Krakens, [Del Rey, 2023]

POSTED BY: Paul Weimer. Ubiquitous in Shadow, but I’m just this guy, you know? @princejvstin.

Statement on Irregularities and Disqualifications within the 2023 Hugo Awards

On January 20, 2024, the full nominating and voting data for the 2023 Hugo, Lodestar and Astounding Awards was finally made public. Normally the data would be released within days of the awards ceremony. The timing is suspect: the data shows an alarming number of irregularities and - worse - disqualifications. These include the novel Babel by R.F. Kuang, which won the 2023 Nebula Award for Best Novel and 2023 Locus Award for Best Fantasy Novel. It also includes Nerds of a Feather, Flock Together editor Paul Weimer, who was nominated in the Best Fan Writer category. The full list of disqualifications is as follows:

Best Novel: R.F. Kuang, Babel
Best Short Story: Hai Ya, "Fongong Temple Pagoda"
Best Fan Writer: Paul Weimer
Best Dramatic Presentation, Short Form: Sandman: "The Sound of Her Wings"
Astounding Award: Xiran Jay Zhao

We, the editorial team of Nerds of a Feather, Flock Together, have attempted to contact the Chengdu Worldcon administrative team to obtain an explanation for these disqualifications; we have received no reply, and emails sent to Chengdu Worldcon's contact address have bounced back. Attempts by others to receive clarification from members of the World Science Fiction Society who are active participants in the administration of the Hugo Awards have similarly been ignored, rebuffed or redirected.

This is unacceptable. We demand immediate explanations for these disqualifications and broader irregularities, and urge the World Science Fiction Society to put concrete, formal protections in place to ensure this does not happen again. The credibility of the 2023 Hugo Awards - and the awards more broadly - are at stake here.


Signed,
The Nerds of a Feather, Flock Together Editorial Team

Novella Project: Green Fuse Burning by Tiffany Morris

Get lost in the swampland in this short novella exploring grief, climate change anxiety, colonization, and mental health.

an Indigenous woman's face is lit in shades of swampy green with some sort of plant growing from her mouth.

Note: Tiffany Morris includes the following content warnings at the beginning of the novella: parental death, suicidal ideation, animal death/gore, explicit sex.

Tiffany Morris’s eco-horror novella Green Fuse Burning keeps a tight focus on place, a large pond, while exploring major issues from grief, PTSD, climate change, colonization, and more. Rita Francis is a Mi’kmaw artist working in landscaping paintings. She goes on a week-long residency paid for by a grant that her white girlfriend, Molly, applied for in her name in hopes of igniting Rita’s artistic spark again. The cabin is on the shore of an isolated pond, and Rita goes early in the season since the warming climate has made the summers too hot and the winters shorter. 

The novella opens with Rita’s first night at the cabin when she’s woken up by what sounds like people dragging a body to the pond. She tries to watch through the window but decides not to go outside. Since she hardly has any cellphone signal at the isolated cabin, she resigns herself that there’s nothing she can do, and she’s not entirely sure what she might have seen was real. She reassures herself: “She’d sleepwalked as a kid, hallucinated all manner of things, found herself waking up on the porch some mornings with muddy feet and the imprint of grass on her arms, impressions of an unknown hour” (13). When she goes into town the next day to ask around, she’s met with the typical rude locals suspect of anyone new, particularly an Indigenous woman.

Rita only has a week at the pond to work on her paintings. Even if the pond seems to have some odd flora and fauna—including some loud and bloody crows—that’s no reason to run away and possibly strain her relationship with her girlfriend even further. But the longer she stays at the pond, the more things unravel. Her girlfriend leaves her a cryptic voicemail, her paintings are oozing, her will to live is fading, and there may or may not be something coming for her from the swamp.

This novella tackles a lot of themes in a tightly plotted story. One of my favorite parts was the meditation on what it means to be an artist. Rita’s livelihood influences her reaction to the weirdness of the pond as she processes it through her paintings. Beyond that, art influences this book, from the great cover, to the inside illustrations. Importantly, the story is structured as if the reader is walking through a gallery of Rita’s work, reading the descriptions of each painting. The following section of the story features some of the inspiration from that painting, and they grow weirder as Rita spirals into the swamp. I loved how the voice of the gallery descriptions differed from the voice of Rita and gave the reader such lines as: “In these paintings we see the murky, urgent depths of a woman’s spiritual journey into the swamplands of uncertainty” (7). Through these paintings and descriptions of Rita’s artistic process, Morris captures one branch of eco-anxiety not depicted as often as a general fear of the changing climate. For artists who work intimately with the land, that change is explored through art, which means a much more intense focus. It’s impossible for the artist to look away from the climate crisis if their chosen focus is landscape, such as Rita. 

While this novella is a fecund meditation on grief and its branching impacts, one of my favorite aspects was the descriptions throughout. Morris’s title comes from the Dylan Thomas poem “The force that through the green fuse drives the flower.” Thomas’s body of work is full of lush, wordy poems, so for Morris’s to draw inspiration from his work—and to quote from the titular poem as an epigraph to the novella—promises the reader an equally lush reading experience. She absolutely delivers, and I enjoyed the natural descriptions throughout, especially as they become weirder and more horrific. One of my favorites opens the second chapter: “As Rita made her way through the fog-wreathed world of the pond loop, she admired the vibrant greens around her with a morbid thrill. […] It invaded, pillaged, choked out everything else that breathed, leaving only a teeming verdant landscape in its wake” (31). Morris’s poetic power of description adds depth to the relatively simple—but effective—plot and makes for a rich reading experience. 

Without dipping into spoilers, the swampy weirdness comes fast and quick. While a more common critique of books is that the middle lagged, in this novella, I wish we had lingered in the middle and let the weirdness build a little more slowly. Morris tackles so many themes—which connect back to the central grief of the death of Rita’s father—but I wish more of these paths could have been explored more fully with a slightly longer novella. Then again, that’s the struggle with the novella form—it’s a snapshot in many ways. Much as Rita’s paintings cannot capture everything about the pond, I found myself wanting to spend a bit more time there in the middle of this novella. 

In her debut novella, Tiffany Morris comes out swinging. This short, tightly plotted novella lives up to the linguistic delight of Dylan Thomas’s work, which is referenced in the title Green Fuse Burning. It also brought to mind Annie Dillard’s foundational work Pilgrim at Tinker Creek (1974) with the connections to animals that don’t quite behave as we would expect. Morris’s meditation on grief, climate change, colonization, art, family, and more reminds the reader of the interconnectedness of life—even after death. In that realization is where I find the power and importance of eco-horror. This subgenre, much like horror in general, offers a way to overcome the fear of climate change and move toward an acceptance of this grotesquely changing world. With this acceptance opens up the possibility to live a fuller life, to keep living, even in the face of terrible loss.

--

Reference: Morris, Tiffany. Green Fuse Burning [Stelliform Press, 2023]

POSTED BY: Phoebe Wagner is an author, editor, and academic writing and living at the intersection of speculative fiction and climate change. 

Wednesday, January 24, 2024

Novella Project: dave ring Interview

Today for the Novella Project we're speaking to dave ring:

Photo by Farrah Skeiky

dave ring is a queer editor and writer of speculative fiction living in Washington, DC. His short fiction has been featured in numerous publications including Lackington’s, Podcastle, and Cossmass Infinities. His novella The Hidden Ones was published in fall 2021 by Rebel Satori Press.

He is the publisher and managing editor of Neon Hemlock Press, and the co-editor of Baffling Magazine. A frequent anthologist, dave edited the Shirley Jackson Award-winning Unfettered Hexes (2021) and the Lambda, Locus, and Ignyte Award-nominated Glitter + Ashes (2020).

dave was a Lambda Literary Fellow in 2013 and chair of the OutWrite LGBTQ Book Festival from 2015-2020. Find him at dave-ring.com or @slickhop on Twitter.

Roseanna speaks to him about his experience publishing novellas with a small press:

How long have you been involved with Neon Hemlock at this point? And what was your starting point with them?

I started Neon Hemlock in the fall of 2019 in order to publish the winning titles of the inaugural OutWrite Chapbook Competition. Shortly after navigating the logistics around printing those chapbooks, I conceived of an anthology idea that would eventually become Glitter + Ashes: Queer Tales of a World That Wouldn’t Die, and things escalated from there. 

What are the particular challenges of running a small press? Especially compared to some of the bigger publishers.

Both reader expectations and industry standards are based on the the bigger publishers. While there are those who enjoy when you defy expectations, there are many hard lines that are challenging to cross as a small press, and often those lines are invisible to the untrained eye. This manifests most prominently in marketing, sales, and distribution.

What is your favourite thing about running a small press?

It’s a great honor to be able to share great writing—electric, important writing—with an engaged audience of readers. There’s also a big endorphin rush whenever I ghetto commission original art. 

Every small press seems to have its particular unique flavour that goes into the works they publish and how they present to the world – what would you say is Neon Hemlock’s?

I expect that the answer to this question is much more interesting when answered by someone besides myself—I’m just one person who has the gall to think that other people might share my personal taste. But the works I think I tend to be drawn to are those written for “in-group” readers, rather than sanitized or clarified for “out-group” readers. I love feeling like I’ve been given a window into something real, rather than a theme park reproduction, and I seek out that feeling with potential submissions.

Neon Hemlock also does an interesting selection of sundry merchandise – I’m sad I can’t currently order all your candles (though it’s probably better for my bank balance this way). How does this fit into your conception of Neon Hemlock’s vibe?

I have the good fortune to be married to a chandler who will tolerate all sorts of foolish ideas when I propose them, which is how we’ve ended up putting out candles called things like “Haunted Cabin” and “Neon Coven.” I find literary accoutrement to be really compelling, so it takes very little encouragement for me to make them for my own titles, regardless of cost or feasibility. 

Does your experience as an author and editor feed into your work running Neon Hemlock? If so, how?

Becoming an editor has certainly improved my own craft, even if by extension I have less time for my own writing. I think the main way being a writer has informed the press is that I try to handle all aspects of the submission process thoughtfully and kindly. I’ve been on the receiving end of some dreadful rejections and I don’t want to create that experience for anyone else.

What goes into your process for finding new works? Do you think there’s a difference compared to the larger publishers?

Most of the work I put out is drawn from open submissions, aside from the occasional solicited novella or the authors I solicit for an anthology. So the delight of discovery is part of the process. I think my process is driven less by the market than larger publishers, so I might be more willing to try a theme or structure that is less proven or more avant-garde. 

So many of Neon Hemlock’s works have fantastic cover art – how do you go about finding the artists for that, and is there much author involvement in the cover art process? How does that work?

I find most illustrators through Twitter or Instagram, often via posts about opening for commissions or the ones that illustrators make for #PortfolioDay. I tend to involve authors in the cover process as much as possible, or as much as they want to be involved. I ask them for examples of covers they like within their genre, and share them when giving initial descriptions to the artist. And then I have them involved again at the thumbnail stage, when we are considering what direction the artist might go in.

You have a particularly interesting and well curated selection of novellas – why is this something you’ve chosen to highlight? Is there something about the novella form that appeals particularly?

Novellas are a really compelling length, and part of what got me reading again during the plague. There’s something very satisfying about a book that you can sink into and finish in a single afternoon, or maybe two if you savor it. 

What do you think makes a good novella more broadly?

Generally, I tend to think that there are two types of novellas: a streamlined novel or an expanded short story. And good novellas of both types have a keen sense of scope, knowing when to linger and when to elide. 

Are there any misconceptions you think people have about novellas? Or about the ones published by small presses? And if so, what would you say in response to them?

This is somewhat of an extension from my previous answer—some people find novellas dissatisfying because of the length, rather than their handling of scope, and critique them based on that dissatisfaction, which feels hardly fair. Readers and editors may disagree regarding the particulars of whether a particular novel succeeds in this area of course, but I think I would encourage such readers to try and enjoy them for what they are instead of wishing they were novels.

Is there anything you’d like to see change in novellas in the near future, or something you think will change?

In terms of publishing, I’d love to see more experimental novellas, and more hybrid forms. In terms of the larger landscape, I’d love to see readers, reviewers and award committees reading more broadly when considering novellas. There are a lot of great presses who are pushing the form right now, and it’d be great to see more names listed beside the books on year-end wrap ups and award ballots. 

Can you tell us about any upcoming novellas you’re excited to be publishing? Or a few works you’ve published in 2023 that you’re particularly proud of?

It’s very hard to pick just one or two to crow about! The book I’ve just sent to the printer is A.Z. Louise’s Off-Time Jive, an alternative history set in a Harlem Renaissance that plays off many of the tropes in both noir and urban fantasy. It has a great voice and beautiful character work too.

Thank you dave!

POSTED BY: Roseanna Pendlebury, the humble servant of a very loud cat. @chloroform_tea

Tuesday, January 23, 2024

Burning Down the Hugo Awards: A Look at the Irregularities in the 2023 Nominating Statistics, What We Know, and What It Means

The Hugo Awards are in the midst of what is almost certainly its most significant crisis in the history of the award, which was first given out in 1953 and continuously since 1955. One might be inclined to say that this is the most significant since the Sad / Rabid Puppy mess in the mid 2010’s, but Marshall Ryan Maresca and others note that this is FAR WORSE and I tend to agree. We’ll get back to that later.

It is a tradition that when the Hugo Awards are presented at a given Worldcon that both the voting and nominating statistics are released that same night. By rule, and we’re going to be talking a lot about rules today, the administering Worldcon has 90 days to publish that data. Unless I’m wrong about time zones (this is possible) - 90 days would have required publication by end of day January 19, 2024. Voting statistics for the final ballot was released on December 3. Nominating statistics were published on January 20.

I’m not going to get into specific conspiracy theories. It would be easy to come up with any number of theories with varying degrees of plausibility, but when the final ballot was released earlier in 2023 the most glaring omission was that R.F. Kuang’s novel Babel was not a Hugo Award finalist. Now, no person or work is guaranteed to make the ballot. Despite Babel’s wide popularity and acclaim, it may have just missed the ballot. Kuang could have declined. It happens. But it got people who were already suspicious of a Worldcon being held in China wondering what happened, especially when word got out that Kuang’s editor, David Pomerico, noted that Kuang did not decline. Thing is, most fans don’t have contact with Pomerico (or Kuang) so there wasn’t a lot of independent verification and it certainly could have been apocryphal. We would wait for the statistics.

A lot of fans, myself included, are always waiting for the statistics. It’s part of how we engage with the Hugo Awards - to see what got close, who declined a nomination, and what the shape of the awards race really looked like.

What we found was that something was really, terribly wrong with the nominating statistics and a lot of things made absolutely no sense.

Babel had the third most nominations and enough to make the Best Novel ballot, but it was ruled ineligible without explanation

Xiran Jay Zhao had enough nominations to make the Astounding Award for Best New Writer ballot, but was ruled ineligible without explanation. Zhao, I should note, was previously a finalist for the Astounding Award, which has a two year eligibility window. This would have been their second year of eligibility.

Paul Weimer had enough nominations to make the Best Fan Writer ballot, but was ruled ineligible without explanation. Paul has been a finalist for Fan Writer the previous three years and was on the ballot in Chengdu as part of the Nerds of a Feather editorial team for Best Fanzine (as well as previously in Best Fancast).

Sandman: Season 1 had enough nominations to make the Dramatic Presentation, Long Form ballot, but was ruled ineligible because of Section 3.8.3 of the WSFS Constitution, which states
“If any series and a subset series thereof both receive sufficient nominations to appear on the final ballot, only the version which received more nominations shall appear.”
This makes sense because Sandman Episode 6 “The Sound of Her Wings” did, in fact, receive more nominations than the full season and sufficient nominations to make the Dramatric Presentation, Short Form ballot. “The Sound of Her Wings” was ruled ineligible without explanation.

The story “Fongong Temple Pagoda” had enough nominations to make the Best Short Story ballot. It was ruled ineligible without explanation.

Other works were also ruled ineligible, some with explanation of previous publication or an author being part of the Hugo subcommittee. Some stories were disqualified because they were legitimately ineligible based on publication date. Additionally, seasons and episodes of the shows Andor and Severance were correctly sorted based on application of 3.8.3, which makes the Sandman situation even more confusing. All of this makes the full rest of the Hugo mess even more confounding.

I want to be a bit pedantic for a moment before I start complaining or digging into the particular responses and lack of responses from the Hugo administrators. Specifically, I want to look at the WSFS Constitution, which are the guiding rules for how the Hugo Awards are administered, and what they say about particular categories. The reason I want to do this is because of the only public statement regarding the ineligibilities is “after reviewing the Constitution and the rules we must follow, the administration team determined those works/persons were not eligible” which is from Dave McCarty the Hugo Award administrator for the Chengdu Worldcon, speaking on his personal facebook page. McCarty’s lack of true explanation or detail is lamentable.

So - let’s dig into what the WSFS Constitution actually has to say.

3.2.1: Unless otherwise specified, Hugo Awards are given for work in the field of science fiction or fantasy appearing for the first time during the previous calendar year.

3.2.3: Publication date, or cover date in the case of a dated periodical, takes precedence over copyright date.
This is the initial basis of eligibility. Awards given in 2023 are for work published in 2022. That is the previous calendar year. On the off chance a work has a 2021 copyright date, the actual publication date of 2022 takes precedence.

Also, this is for works of science fiction and fantasy, or relating to the field of science fiction and fantasy, depending on the particular category.

If we take a look at R.F. Kuang’s novel Babel, this is a novel that was first published in 2022 and is demonstrably a work of fantasy. It is an alternate history with magic. In 2023 Babel won a Nebula Award, the Locus Magazine Reader’s Poll for Best Fantasy novel, and was nominated for the World Fantasy Award, Dragon Award, Ignyte Award, and Sidewise Awards - all for excellence in the science fiction and fantasy field.

The specific additional rules for Best Novel, beyond the publication date and genre requirements are:
3.2.7: The categories of Best Novel, Novella, Novelette, Short Story, and Series shall be open to non-interactive works in which the text is the primary form of communication, regardless of the publication medium, including but not limited to physical print, audiobook, and ebook

3.3.1: Best Novel. A science fiction or fantasy story of forty thousand (40,000) words or more
That’s it. Babel is decidedly a text based work, and it is significantly over 40,000 words (likely topping 160,000 words).

I would absolutely love an explanation for how Babel is not eligible for the Hugo Award for Best Novel.

Now, if we look at the curious case of Paul Weimer, I’m going to be quoting a whole bunch of category descriptions because Paul was declared ineligible as a Fan Writer and Fan Writer is a category that weirdly depends on other categories.

3.3.17: Best Fan Writer. Any person whose writing has appeared in semiprozines or fanzines or in generally available electronic media during the previous calendar year.

3.3.14: Best Semiprozine. Any generally available non-professional periodical publication devoted to science fiction or fantasy, or related subjects which by the close of the previous calendar year has published four (4) or more issues (or the equivalent in other media), at least one (1) of which appeared in the previous calendar year, which does not qualify as a fancast, and which in the previous calendar year met at least one (1) of the following criteria:

(1) paid its contributors and/or staff in other than copies of the publication,

(2) was generally available only for paid purchase,

3.3.15: Best Fanzine. Any generally available non-professional periodical publication devoted to science fiction, fantasy, or related subjects that by the close of the previous calendar year has published four (4) or more issues (or the equivalent in other media), at least one (1) of which appeared in the previous calendar year, that does not qualify as a semiprozine or a fancast, and that in the previous calendar year met neither of the following criteria:

(1) paid its contributors or staff monetarily in other than copies of the publication,

(2) was generally available only for paid purchase.
Now that we have that out of the way, Fan Writer assumes that first the work was done in 2022 and that it was done in either Fanzines or Semiprozines. I’ll admit that I don’t know the full scope of Paul’s work over 2022 because he is truly ubiquitous, but I know this: Paul was a writer and editor of Nerds of a Feather, which is explicitly a fanzine. We are a previous winner of the Best Fanzine Hugo Award and we were on the ballot in Chengdu for Best Fanzine (with Paul as a listed finalist). Paul produced something like 60 pieces of writing for Nerds of a Feather, so I don’t see any reason why someone who is so prominent in online fandom who produces fan writing all over the place (not just at Nerds of a Feather, but specifically here) is in some way not eligible in the Fan Writer category. Here is his initial response. 

I just don’t know how someone who has been a three time Fan Writer finalist who is continually producing the same sort of work in the same sort of spaces that got him on the ballot thrice before is suddenly not eligible. This does not make sense.

None of this makes sense, but the ineligibility of Xiran Jay Zhao for the Astounding Award for Best New Writer is perhaps the most baffling of all.

The Astounding Award is technically not a Hugo Award, but it is administered by the presiding Worldcon along with the Hugo Awards. This matters because the rules are set by Dell Magazines and not the World Science Fiction Society.

The pertinent rules are in the award's FAQ
Who is eligible for the 2023 Astounding Award?

Writers with a qualifying professional work published in 2021 or 2022. Eligibility does not reset with pseudonyms. Each writer has a two year eligibility window after publishing a qualifying work.

What counts as a qualifying professional work?

Any work of fiction in the science fiction or fantasy genres (SF/F) published in a qualifying publication.

Which publications qualify?

Any publication meeting one of the following criteria:

Copy print run of at least 10,000

Publications which have a nominal pay rate, particularly those designated by the award sponsor (Dell Magazines). The nominal rate was originally taken from SFWA membership requirements, which was $0.08/word with a minimum of $80 total.

A published work of fiction of a minimum of 40,000 words either sold to a small press or self-published for which the author can demonstrate net income of at least $3,000 within one year. Income can be in the form of advance, royalties, or some combination thereof.
Xiran Jay Zhao’s first professional publication was the novel Iron Widow in 2021. They were an Astounding Award finalist in 2022 in their first year of eligibility. Zhao was in their second year of eligibility, and as previously mentioned the Astounding Award has a two year eligibility window. Zhao was explicitly eligible the year prior and as nothing changed, Zhao should absolutely be eligible in 2023.

And yet.
 
I do not know enough about “Fongong Temple Pagoda”, its provenance or publication dates other than being told that it was published in 2022 and otherwise fits the category. I’m not comfortable going into detail about something I can’t accurately source - but it is the only disqualified story that could not be easily demonstrated to be ineligible.

Dave McCarty stated “after reviewing the Constitution and the rules we must follow, the administration team determined those works/persons were not eligible” and then followed that with the only other bit of clarification he was willing to offer: “That is the statement the Hugo administration team agreed to after long and considered deliberation.” (again, via his personal Facebook account).

That is a non response. It is unacceptable, and frankly it is bullshit.

Dave McCarty is specifically listed as a Vice Chair of the Chengdu Worldcon and a Department Head of the Hugo Awards Selection Executive Department. He is also listed as part of the Awards Administration.

https://en.chengduworldcon.com/news20/

https://www.thehugoawards.org/hugo-history/2023-hugo-awards/

This is not to say that McCarty is solely responsible for this hot mess of a Hugo Awards (which was up until the release of the data, otherwise lovely) but he is, for better or worse (and mostly worse) the public face of this fiasco and based on his roles and his public statements - he was part of this.

But now we get into speculation because in the absence of transparent communication and actual answers that are demonstrably real and factual all we have left is speculation.

So let’s speculate, starting with R.F. Kuang’s public statement.
I wish to clarify that no reason for Babel’s ineligibility was given to me or my team. I did not decline a nomination, as no nomination was offered.

Until one is provided that explains why the book was eligible for the Nebula and Locus awards, which it won, and not the Hugos, I assume this was a matter of undesirability rather than ineligibility. Excluding “undesirable” work is not only embarrassing for all involved parties, but renders the entire process and organization illegitimate. Pity.

That’s honestly the heart of most of the speculation - that Kuang and Weimer and Zhao and Sandman and “Fongong Temple Pagoda” were deemed ineligible not because there was any factual basis on the ineligibility, which I believe I have clearly shown that they was not, but rather because a decision was made by *someone* that maaaaybe these people / works would be better left off the ballot.

Cheryl Morgan notes that “they have chosen to put out a set of nomination statistics that makes it very clear that shenanigans have taken place. Maybe we should be thinking about why they did that.”

Tammy Coxen, on McCarty’s Facebook suggests exactly that. “The fact that he did release them, in a way that made it abundantly clear that there were irregularities should be taken as the message that it is”

Except that Dave McCarty is doubling down on the integrity of how the Hugo Award were administered.

Everything that appeared on the ballot and was voted on was put there by the (world wide) Worldcon community. We have detailed stats at the end showing everything was nominated and the identifies all of the decisions the administration team made.

I look at that and I see both legitimacy and transparency.

If he is protecting people, that is admirable but he is also burning down the integrity of the Hugo Awards at the same time. McCarty responds with belligerent and functionally stating that nobody has any idea how anything works, does not know anything, and reading of the WSFS Constitution does not make one an expert.

Perhaps not, but it does allow us to ask questions. It does allow a lot of people with significant experience to ask questions because this doesn’t add up.

When the Sad / Rabid Puppies fiasco occurred, the Worldcon response was that while awful and unacceptable nothing that was done was actually against the rules so a whole lot of otherwise awful finalists made the Hugo ballot because the Hugo Awards were administered fairly and by the rules of the WSFS Constitution.

Worldcon members then acted to make changes to the WSFS Constitution to minimize the impact of such bad actors, but that was also done in accordance to the rules of the World Science Fiction Society. It wasn’t done by fiat.

Naomi Kritzer stated in that same Facebook thread where McCarty claimed legitimacy and transparency, addressing Dave:
You were literally the Hugo administrator in 2016, a year when Puppies took over the ballot, and you opted not to disqualify such nominees as "If You Were an Award, My Love" in short story, “Safe Space as Rape Room” by Daniel Eness and "SJWs Always Lie" in Related Work, and Vox Day in Editor Long Form.

I think that year we were all told that it would be perfectly impossible to disqualify anything, because rules. Fascinating that you found a way to disqualify Rebecca Kuang but not Theodore Beale.
That’s damning.

That’s why what is going on now is so much worse than the Sad / Rabid Puppies - because everything that we can see is the rules were *not* followed and that makes this entire experience illegitimate because we can no longer trust that the Hugo Awards will be administered fairly and with integrity.

Maybe we’re all missing something, but when all we have are the increasingly defensive and angry replies of a man claiming that everything is on the up and up because he says they are and anyone with a lick of sense can see that there is something wrong here - there’s something wrong here and it is damaging the credibility of the Hugo Awards and we’re watching it in real time.

What I do think is a serious possibility, which is equally damning for the integrity of the Hugo Awards, is that - in the face of McCarty saying that nobody directly told the Hugo Committee that the administering Hugo Award Committee took it upon themselves in the face of invisible political pressure to make choices that would not run the risk of causing even a potential issue with the local / regional / national political committees in China. And thus, without anyone saying anything or telling anyone to disqualify legitimate nominees, R.F. Kuang, Xiran Jay Zhao, Paul Weimer, Sandman, and "Fongong Temple Pagoda" find themselves mysteriously "ineligible" for a Hugo Award. 

And if there is a concern that in the future other Hugo Committees could make similar decisions, what is the Hugo Award anyway?

None of this even gets into the potential shenanigans of the actual nominating numbers, which are also deeply suspect but a potential symptom of this larger issue.


Note: Information in this essay is as accurate as I could make it up until the time it published, after which I have no idea what is going to happen next or be revealed next. Stay tuned, because this hot mess is not going anywhere


Joe Sherry - Senior Editor of Nerds of a Feather. Hugo and Ignyte Winner. Minnesotan.

Novella Project: Filip Hajdar Drnovšek Zorko Interview

Today for the Novella Project, we're talking to Filip Hajdar Drnovšek Zorko:

Filip Hajdar DrnovÅ¡ek Zorko is a Slovenian-born writer and translator. He grew up in Slovenia, Ireland, Australia, and the UK, and currently resides just outside Portland, Maine. He understands that his name is a bit confusing and would like you to know that “DrnovÅ¡ek Zorko” is the surname. He attended Clarion West in 2019, and his work has previously appeared in Clarkesworld, Strange Horizons, and Lightspeed, among others. In his spare time he is a keen quizzer—British readers may recognise him from that one time he was on University Challenge. Follow him on Twitter and Bluesky @filiphdz.

What made you write Between Blades as a novella? Was it a conscious plan from the start, or something that naturally evolved through the process?


The main thing was finishing writing a novel and saying nope, not doing that again*. I wrote Between Blades years ago, before I knew I wanted to take writing more seriously - it was my first ever story submission of any kind! - and looking back, I'm surprised by how joyful the experience of writing it was. Writing a novel is daunting. I'm forever thinking about structure, which I hate. Short stories are hard in the other direction. I'm always worrying they'll spiral out of control. A novella is both at once: a long short story, or a short novel. There's something freeing about that - but strangely enough, I haven't written another one since. Maybe I'm worried the first time was a fluke. (I do have ideas for several, including both a prequel and a sequel to this one!)


*narrator voice: he did that again.


When you sit down to write a story, what's the thing you start with - worldbuilding, plot, characters, ideas, something else entirely? And how do you decide what comes next?


Usually a story accretes around the relationship between two characters; but usually, all the other elements have been bouncing around my head, looking for an outlet, so I'm not sure it's accurate to say I start there. It's more like, once I know I want to write a story about some characters, I rummage around to see if I've already got a world or a plot or a cool concept that would fit.


You've had a number of short stories published in various magazines - was there any difference in the process for this? Or anything you think you'd do differently if you did ever write another novella?


I'd say the biggest difference is I wrote my short stories with a much better understanding of the publishing industry! That's a pro and a con, and it probably ties into my wariness with writing more novellas. Short stories are (relatively) quick to write and there's a lot of markets for them. These days if I write a short I feel reasonably confident I can get it published. Novellas are different. Despite the popularity of the form (with readers AND writers!), novellas are paradoxically hard to get published. For unagented writers, there's a limited number of small presses and magazines that publish a handful of novellas a year, and it's a rare agent who'll take on a client on the strength of a novella alone. The same inbetween-ness that makes them a joy to write also makes them frustrating to find homes for. Don't get me wrong, I'm not out here minmaxing all my writing for optimal career advancement, but when I have lots of projects to work on, it's easy to defer the novella-sized ones until some nebulous future when the path to publishing them will be easier.


Given all that, how did Between Blades come to be published in Beneath Ceaseless Skies? Was it something you just sent for open submissions or something more directed?


It was the ol' "have a drink with the editor" that did it for me. I'd sold a few shorter stories to Scott but I didn't meet him in person until this year's Readercon, where I mentioned in passing I had this novella I was trying to place. He invited me to submit it to BCS, which was a pleasant surprise, because I actually hadn't realised he occasionally published novellas. Lest I feed the narrative that publishing is all about connections and bar-based networking, I think the real lesson here is to be enthusiastic about your work, even (especially) the unpublished stuff. Someone might be looking for just the story you've written, but they'll never know to ask if you don't talk about it!


Talk to people? Horrifying thought :P


Flipping back to novellas more generally, you talk about the joy of writing them, but what do you think are the strengths of the format from a reader's perspective?


They're the exact right length to read on a lazy weekend afternoon. They can linger like a novel but be focused like a short story. They're like Macbeth to a novel's Hamlet. I think these are all ways of saying the same thing.


I feel like there’s a whole essay in your thoughts about Macbeth and Hamlet there, but possibly not to the purpose of this discussion. We can take that offline, as the business people say.


Moving onto Between Blades more specifically, the setting draws on aspects of the Roman empire, both in the gladiatorial games as well as in the bureaucracy, as many stories have done before. Why did you choose to go there, and what do you think it's doing for the story?


Follow up question: I find it very interesting that you have two key figures in your story called Livia and Agrippa - were they specific choices, or conveniently Roman-sounding names, or something else/in between?


Part of it was the constraint of doing a lot of worldbuilding in a smallish space. I wasn't drawing on any one culture for Leshin and the archipelago in general, which is how I prefer my fantasy worldbuilding, but that does require a little more work. In the opening half, which is where all the archipelago scenes take place, the slower pace allowed for that depth to the worldbuilding. In the latter half, the plot and the character arcs are well in progress, so it was useful to have a setting that felt familiar - it let me focus on the details that really mattered to Leris while the reader sketched in the rest.


I went with Rome as my model because, I mean, yes, gladiators and bureaucracy, but once I started thinking about it, it felt right in other ways, too. I particularly wanted to evoke the sense of a large, complex, contradictory state - the sort of place where it's not entirely clear if everyone agrees they're part of the same empire. Emona and Traiti are at odds. Livia and Agrippa are at odds. There's strict class hierarchies, too, and a confusing religion. When Leris arrives, having only experienced the Empire as a looming, hegemonic presence in the archipelago, she's immediately put into friction with this reality. It was also a small opportunity to insert myself into the story! Fun fact time: Slovenia's only been an independent country slightly longer than I've been alive, which I think is responsible for a recurring contradiction in my writing, between belonging and not. Part of but not heart of, if you like. I knew right away that I wanted to take the story somewhere other than the heart of the Empire, and why not borrow the Roman name for Ljubljana, where I was born?


As for the characters - gosh, I can't pretend I remember exactly. Livia, I think, was a specific choice. I liked the idea of putting the first Roman Empress in her husband's place, and from there it made sense to borrow the name of one of his close friends for Livia's closest friend (slash enemy).


Incidentally, I was doing the edits for Between Blades right around the time the Roman Empire was making waves on social media. I can neither confirm nor deny the frequency with which I was thinking about the Roman Empire at that time.


Picking up on the belonging part of your answer - a lot of the centre of the narrative is about that, about fitting into boxes other people make for you. Or... well, not. As a story, it's extremely gender, in the best way possible. How do you go about writing something with that strong of a message at the heart without it overwhelming the rest of the story, or likewise being overwhelmed? Especially when you only have a novella length of time to fit it into?


I think of speculative fiction as a magnifying glass. Some people feel emotions very strongly and with great certainty, and maybe they don’t need a magnifying glass, but I do. Otherwise it’s like trying to sort sand with tweezers. I’ll know that there’s something in there, in that handful of sand, a feeling or an emotion, that’s worth writing a story about it. But I won’t really know what it is until I’ve teased it out and separated it from the rest, and for that I need a magnifying glass.


I don’t really think of those two things - the emotional core of the story and the fantastical elements that make up the plot - as being in opposition. Leris’s journey is my grain of sand. The rest is the magnifying glass. One can’t overwhelm the other because they do not compete for the same space but occupy it together, one laid over the other.


Speculative fiction is good at this because it is, by definition, larger than life.


In terms of that emotional core, are there any books or authors you think do it particularly well, or ones you draw inspiration from or look to when you're writing yourself? Bonus points if they're novellas.


They’re certainly not novellas, but I want to mention Arkady Martine’s Teixcalaan books and CL Clark’s Magic of the Lost, which are very different series but share a knack for anchoring large-scale concepts of empire and identity in the emotions and relationships of their protagonists. I do love bonus points, though, so I’d be remiss not to mention Kai Ashante Wilson’s A Taste of Honey - a solid contender for the best love story I’ve ever read, with the sort of speculative twist that gently rearranges your understanding of the story.


A Taste of Honey is a masterpiece. I finished it then immediately wanted to bite it because reading it with my eyes simply wasn't sufficient.


Thinking in terms of novellas specifically, are there any trends you think might come up in the next few years, or changes you'd like to see in the format?


I have an interesting answer and a boring answer and I'll let you decide which is which. First, I'd like to see more series of novellas. I like the current trend in SFF of standalone novels that feel like they would have been trilogies back in the day - The Priory of the Orange Tree, Some Desperate Glory, and their ilk - but what if we experimented with trilogies where each installment is much shorter? (Half-Life 2 fans, avert your eyes.) In terms of total word count they'd stack up about the same, I think, so I'd be curious to see what changes when you draw sharper divides between sections of the story. Second, I'd like to see some reappraisal of the word count limits for award categories. I'm in the weeds here, I know, but those word limits are the reason we care about words like "novelette" and "novella" to begin with. At present there's an artificial gap between about forty and sixty thousands words where stories are too long for many novella publishers but too short to be marketed as a novel, so by and large they don't get published. (One exception is In the Vanisher's Palace by Aliette de Bodard, which is one of my favourite novellas.) Novellas have always been a bridge between short fiction and books, so perhaps a level of falling-through-the-cracks is inevitable, but the publishing landscape has changed massively since those limits were set. It's a good time for a rethink.


And then last question - can you tell us a bit more about Between Blades? 


Between Blades (or ebook version) is a novella about gladiators who turn into weapons, the pervasive power of hegemony, and finding yourself in the spaces between cultures. It's about the friendship between the living embodiment of the term "spear queer" and a woman who mostly just wants to be left alone to chill with her twin brother. Ultimately, if you like stories where all the fight scenes are actually stand-ins for discussions of identity and belonging, this is for you.


Thank you Filip!

POSTED BY: Roseanna Pendlebury, the humble servant of a very loud cat. @chloroform_tea

Monday, January 22, 2024

The Wheel of Time Reread: The Path of Daggers

Welcome back, dear readers, to The Wheel of Time Reread. Today we’re going to talk about The Path of Daggers, the eighth book in the series.

We are now more than halfway through The Wheel of Time regardless of how we count New Spring (the prequel novel) and friends, we have officially hit The Slog. I think my definition of the slog has changed over the years, with it starting as early as Lord of Chaos (Dumai’s Wells not withstanding) and pretty definitively running through Crossroads of Twilight. This time through I could see the beginning of that muddy road in A Crown of Swords but truly felt it here.

Things happen. Some pretty significant things even. And yet.

I think part of the idea of the Wheel of Time slog if you had been reading the series as it was written / published (hi, it’s me) you noticed that the time between books had increased to two years between books rather than just one and if you couple that with the narrative pace likewise slowing down around this time it was a frustrating time to be a Wheel of Time reader. Where this really comes up, and I will absolutely talk about this when we get to Crossroads of Twilight is that in that book it had been two years since this really awesome, world changing event, and then…it’s a bunch of characters noticing something is happening pretty far away and for the most part it’s just Robert Jordan catching everyone up to that moment, except that none of the characters had any idea what was going on so it didn’t have a significant impact. And then it was *another* two and a half years until Knife of Dreams - which happily was awesome.

But, with that, the idea of the slog coalesced, I think, because of the disappointment of how Crossroads of Twilight was handled and it pushed back into these slightly earlier novels because the signs and symptoms of what was to come really started here.

Except - upon a reread that stagnation is no longer as glaring as it once was because the only delay between reading The Path of Daggers and starting Winter’s Heart is my willingness to pick up the next book (or, in the case of the single volume Wheel of Time ebook I’m reading this on - to turn another page). That’s why even though I’m spending more time writing about the slog than I had expected to, it’s much more of a idiosyncratic idea that changes on each read through of the series.

To work through all of that and to get to the next book, we do need to actually talk about this one - and to do that, there shall be spoilers.

Before I touch on those actual plot moments, such as they are, let’s talk about Verin. From her first appearance Verin has been a favorite - which is something that the show gets very right. What, did you think that just because we’re between seasons that I’m not going to work in a reference to the delightful show? Of course I am!

The prologue has an extended Verin section and I really wish I could remember when I first started to ask questions about her but readers should be asking questions about Verin after The Path of Daggers. There are several bits here - things about “questionable” weaves, her wondering if she had an opportunity to arrange for an accident for an escaped Aes Sedai, and the final line about ensuring Rand lives long enough until it’s time for him to die. The thing about Rand specifically is clearly meant to be ominous and over-considered and argued about and throughout the series there have been multiple references to prophecies and visions where Rand / The Dragon will shed his blood on the rocks at Shayol Ghul, that a character will help him die, he price Rand must pay, “twice to live and twice to die” and more so there can be any possible explanation for why Verin is considering that Rand must live long enough until it’s time for him to die.

The rest of it, Verin using questionable weaves and wondering about killing an escaped Aes Sedai - that’s not quite what we’re expecting from our heroes. And Verin is an Aes Sedai and our favorite so of course she’s a hero, but this is very strongly suggesting that something is wrong with Verin.

I suspect I’m not going to spend a lot of time thinking about Perrin over the next several books because we’re about to lead into one of my least favorite storylines. I haven’t thus far enjoyed a single thing about Masema, the batshit insane “Prophet” of the Dragon who has a fervent cult of murderous unwashed followers. Perrin’s mission is to approach Masema and get him to stand down (with an implication to stand down or be stood down) because Masema’s cult army has been a scourge upon Randland and if anything is going to unite the world against Rand such as might be possible it’s the actions of a rogue group purportedly following Rand.

Getting Perrin and Masema to reunite, however, leads into Faile being captured / kidnapped by the Shaido Aiel - and THAT storyline has historically been my least favorite in the series, though that point I don’t remember just how many books it takes. The kidnapping looms large enough that it feels like Perrin is chasing after Faile and the Shaido for something like four novels, but it certainly could have been just Winter’s Heart and Crossroads of Twilight - which given that the kidnapping happens at the very end of this book wouldn’t be nearly as long as it feels like it is. It’s something to not look forward to in the upcoming re-read.

Something much more interesting to me is the use of The Bowl of Winds to fix the Dark One’s touch on the weather and end the unnatural endless summer (but with much less surfing). It’s been a story arc crossing several books, which might suggest that maybe I don’t need to complains so much about Faile’s capture but I tend to appreciate Elayne and Nynaeve as characters much more than I do Perrin and Faile, so even though it’s taken a while to finally get here I think it’s a much better journey.

It’s a fairly dramatic scene and is a major use of magic to steer the weather onto a new course, and the bowl weirdly uses saidin even though saidin is not channeled into it, and takes a whole lot of people to come together to make it happen. It is, of course, part of a bargain so we’ve got Aes Sedai, the Kin, and Sea Folk all working together. It’s beautiful and incredibly reluctant and fraught with tension and that’s great too because Nynaeve is perpetually annoyed and put out and that always leads to some fantastic dramatic irony.

The end result of all of that (besides the actual use of the bowl) is that our Super Friends escape from a Seanchan invasion / war party, Elayne finds out exactly what happens when you mess around with picking apart a weave (things go boom), and we begin another lingering storyline - which is Elayne returns to Andor (finally!) to claim her throne. It’s a process because Andor doesn’t necessarily just go to the next in line, especially with Elayne’s absence from Caemlyn taken into consideration.

I do tend to enjoy political infighting, especially when there are no Forsaken-given headaches, so I’m down for Elayne claiming her throne and ready for the lingering Egwene storyline to keep moving.

Egwene, of course, is slooooooowly working her way towards besieging the White Tower because fuck Elaida, but we’re getting to the best Egwene (Knife of Dreams Egwene) so I dig all of the moments where she can - step by baby step - claim the authority of the Amyrlin Seat for herself and operate as an Amyrlin in her own right. Suian correctly identifies just how thin of an knife edge Egwene is walking but it’s do nothing and be a puppet or risk it all and save the world.

Rand goes to war in The Path of Daggers and despite being the true protagonist of the entire series (and technically the point of it all) - I could almost always use less Rand than we get here - but he takes the fight to the Seanchan, gets overconfident, uses Callandor for the first time since The Dragon Reborn but because he’s fighting where the Bowl of Winds was used and the Bowl did “weird things” to saidin in the area nobody can really control saidin and Callandor exasperates the problem and Rand makes everything explode and killed a bunch of people on both sides of the battle. It’s ugly, because war is ugly. The Wheel of Time doesn’t glamorize war by any stretch of the imagination, but Rand’s fight against the Seanchan really uglies it up to another level.

Also of note is the betrayal of Rand by several Asha’man - it’s a frantic sequence that leads to Taim showing up both just in time and also just after it would have been too late. Dashiva’s betrayal doesn’t make Taim less suspicious of a character and his leading the Asha’man has long been a questionable decision Rand made - but now we know for sure there is rot at the core of the Black Tower.

As mentioned, big and exciting stuff happens in The Path of Daggers, but it’s also a novel that is just kind of there. It’s easy to think about a different version of The Wheel of Time where A Crown of Swords, The Path of Daggers, Winter’s Heart, and Crossroads of Twilight are all condensed into a much tighter two volume middle set - which maybe would be too rushed compared to the rest of the series. The Path of Daggers and Winter’s Heart are already the two shortest books in the series, but it’s a fun exercise to think about how and where to tighten up the storylines.

Next Up: Winter’s Heart, in which things happen (probably). Plus: the daughter of nine moons, a three way warder bonding, chasing a falcon, and a magical cleansing.





Joe Sherry - Senior Editor of Nerds of a Feather. Hugo and Ignyte Winner. Minnesotan.