Worlds enough and time?

[Note: There some light spoilers in this review. I avoid large ones, or anything substantial further than 20% into the book.]
Claire North is simply incapable of writing a bad novel. From their early work under their birth name (Catherine Webb), to their excellent urban fantasy as Kate Griffin and the huge stylistic and thematic sweep of work under their current moniker (ranging from Homeric historicals through LeCarre pastiche through space opera), they have produced a couple of dozen novels which bottom out at “really good.” On top of this extremely high base, the best of their oeuvre is as good as any speculative fiction produced over the past twenty years. Last year’s space opera-meets-thumpingly unsubtle jeremiad against climate inaction and late capitalism, Slow Gods, was top tier North (and shortlisted for the LeGuin Prize), and As We Fall Through Time is, remarkably, operating at the same level. It will, I’m sure, end up being one of the best novels I read this year.
Having just said that North’s work spans a wide range of themes and subgenres, I do think their most common mode seems to be the speculative thriller, using a key speculative premise to set up very well-crafted, often character-driven, action. After departing from that space with Slow Gods and their previous Songs of Penelope trilogy, they return to more typical territory in As We Fall Through Time. The key speculative premise here is that some very few people are born in circumstances where they might never have existed had the proverbial butterfly flapped its wings at a slightly different time. These people both do and no not exist in permanent quantum superposition, and as a side effect are able to slip through time via buildings or terrain which exist both in their current time and in the time to which they wish to travel.
Our protagonist is Cal, a time traveller whose gender is as fluid as their place in the timestream (as with the neurodiverse protagonist of Slow Gods, this reads somewhat as North working through something about themself in fiction). The inciting incident is a hookup: in Paris looking for an object with unusual temporal qualities in the early days of the French Revolution, Cal (male at this point) runs into a solider named Olivier and ends up going home with him. This one-night stand, basically accidentally, expands to genuine affection and eventually a long-standing, loving relationship. Olivier resolutely refuses to ask too many questions about the interventions Cal makes to keep him alive, from mysterious pills when he is ill (antibiotics fetched from the 21st century) to completely implausible appearances from Cal to save Olivier while he’s off on military campaigns during the Napoleonic Wars. And Cal keeps using his time travel abilities to make such interventions, up to and including ones which deny someone he loves a fair bit of agency.
[This paragraph is where a spoiler for 20% in is discussed, so skip this paragraph if you're sensitive to such.] The bold choice the book makes is that, about 1/5 the way through, Olivier runs out of rope despite Cal’s heroic efforts. One day, Cal comes home and Olivier has been erased from the timeline: not dead, but never existed. I hasten to add that, in a book about time travellers where playing with causality and paradox are major themes, this erasure, while of course devastating to Cal, is not something they take lying down, nor is it necessarily the end of their story with Olivier. Cal’s struggle to understand what happened to his husband—and another paradox-implicating murder a fellow time traveller asks them to investigate—kickstarts the plot into full gear. At first glance I read this narrative choice as a gender-flipped version of the classic girlfriend fridging to motivate the main character. But as I read more, as Cal’s grief kept piling up and their time traveler colleagues never quite manage to understand it or who Olivier was to them, I realised North was perhaps doing something more clever and far more devastating: literalising the very real phenomenon of queer couples and queer domesticity being (figuratively) erased from history. This sort of thing from historians is well known enough that there is a meme about it: “they seem to be very good friends.” But it also happens outside the bounds of formal written history: it was distressingly common for queer couples through the mid 20th century to have their photos, their letters, the record of their lives together burned to ashes by homophobic families after their deaths. In As We Fall Through Time, Cal has had this done to his relationship with Olivier by time itself. Read in this way, much of the book is almost unbearably moving, particularly because North never descends to the maudlin.
Once these murder mystery plots get going, it becomes clear the book is doing quite a lot of things, all very well, in a short page count. As Cal investigates how a particular body appeared in Seoul at a particular time—and where Olivier might have gone—we also get something of an out-of-order Bildungsroman subplot for them, with various elements of their backstory and future playing out and explaining how the compelling character we see at the start of the novel came into being. We also slowly see an eco-thriller strand become central to the story: it turns out climate change is, directly or indirectly, going to lead to the extinction of humanity within 500 years or so. If you’re a time traveller, of course you’re going to try to convince people to change course at some point before it becomes too late to do so, and maybe those efforts will have some unforeseen consequences of their own.
In tone and approach, As We Fall Through Time reminds me of one of my favourite earlier North books, The Gameshouse (originally a trilogy of ebook novellas). As with the supernatural gamblers in The Gameshouse, the time travellers in this novel are hidden agents behind the scenes playing in history. Some are merely playing; idle immortals looking to hang out with John Lennon or sleep with Cleopatra and the like. Some use their powers to enrich themselves, and some try to shift events in ways they’d prefer. But in a way The Gameshouse really didn’t (it was huge fun, but to my mind didn’t have a clear normative take on the amoral games it depicted beyond a slight anarchic streak), North here is clearly contemptuous of the shits that treat history as their private playground. They’re also incandescently furious about the selfishness inherent in the choices over decades that have led to runaway climate change. Late in the novel, Fadimatu, one of Cal’s time travelling colleagues and a historian, says, “What is history, Cal, if not the story of people choosing, every day, in every single moment, and then living with the consequences? We should live with consequences. Living without is what makes people cruel.” Impunity, more than anything else, stands condemned.
Oddly enough, given this book is actually about climate change, it is not as unsubtle and occasionally on the nose as Slow Gods was with the same themes; the narrative has earned that explicit statement by the time North has Fadimatu say it. The tone is ultimately fatalistic but not hopeless. Threading that needle is no easy task, and it’s an illustration of North’s fine touch as a writer that they manage it (the ripped from the headlines anti-AI drive-bys, despite me entirely agreeing with the sentiment, are somewhat less successful).
All of this is delivered in prose that is incisive and interesting at the sentence level and extremely effective in using missing and non-standard punctuation, line breaks, and page layout to convey the disconnection and dislocation as the narrative slips through time. Techniques like these risk coming across as too-clever games, but in North’s hand they come across as correct and inevitable. The narration is also hugely characterful, an omniscient first person that, it becomes clear as the narrative develops, is actually a person who has been witness to the events of the novel, a dangling question for the reader that eventually is answered with the most audacious flourish; I actually cackled out loud when I worked out what they were doing. The whole thing is a hell of a ride, and while you don’t always know where you’re going, you can trust that Claire North, as per usual, is taking you somewhere far more interesting than most.
Highlights:
- Weaves multiple plot threads together into a hugely satisfying narrative
- Brilliantly written with vivid narration
- A love story, to its time-twisted core
Nerd coefficient: 8/10.
Reference: North, Claire. As We Fall Through Time [Orbit, 2026].
POSTED BY: Eddie Clark. Professional nerd by day, amateur nerd by night. @dreddieclark.bsky.social