Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Book Review: Hokey Pokey by Kate Mascarenhas

 Cannibal cryptid psychoanalysis, for your reading pleasure

Judging from the reviews of this book on Storygraph, it suffers not from any lack of quality (TL;DR: it’s fantastic and I loved it so, so much) but from a severe case of mismarketing, and that is deeply unfortunate. Let me set things straight right now:

It is not a murder mystery in an art-deco era hotel in Birmingham.

It is not a story of two women entangled with the same man coming to value each other, with queerness and mutual support as each learns that the man is a worthless waste of space.

It is not a feminist tale about a woman struggling to build professional careers, hampered by early 20th-century sexism in the medical profession.

It is not a tale of a woman who has rebuilt herself after a catastrophic childhood mistake revealed the depths of her family’s fucked-upedness, only to be forced to face the consequences of that mistake decades later.

All of these things are core elements of the book, yes. Absolutely these things happen. Already you can tell that this book is rich and layered, and invites the reader to engage in multiple conversations that would make for a very effective literary historical fiction tale. But if you went into this book expecting such a thing, you would be very, very surprised to discover that it is not this at all. Because—whoof, my goodness, this is a book in which deeply messed up people embrace their messiness with a whole-hearted self-awareness that leaves you simultaneously appalled, impressed, and rooting for them.

Our main character, Dr. Nora Dickinson, is a psychoanalyst, based in Europe, but visiting the Regent Hotel, Birmingham, because her ex-lover Leo (also a psychoanalyst) has asked her to spy on his wife Berenice, who he suspects is cheating on him. Nora has an uncanny ability to remember and repeat people’s words and voices with perfect fidelity, and for this reason makes a good spy: her reports are undeniably accurate, and Leo—an utter fucker—quite likes her ability to imitate Berenice’s voice. Nora, a smart lady who knows what she wants, for some baffling reason wants Leo, so she agrees to assist him on his quest. If she can find evidence of Berenice’s infidelity, she reasons, Leo will drop Berenice. Furthermore, the more she observes Berenice, the better she can imitate her, which Leo likes, because he is gross. The end goal is that Leo will take Nora as the newer, better version of Berenice, one who can imitate her exactly in voice and mannerism, but who will be devoted and faithful.

Like, ew, right? Both unfair to Berenice, but also wildly unhealthy on Nora’s part. You’d think a psychoanalyst—and a skilled one, at that—would be able to recognize all the problems with this plan. But Nora simply doesn’t think about it in that way. And—something I really appreciated—the narrative itself doesn’t particularly care about whether this train of reasoning is healthy or unhealthy. That’s not what this book is about. We are given a character with a particular set of abilities, a well defined goal, and a focused determination to achieve that goal, and we are relieved of the moral obligation to have opinions about the rightness or wrongness of this state of affairs.

This is so freeing in a narrative! It is the psychological equivalent of a rogue vigilante deploying self-defined justice, beating up bystanders until they tell him what he wants to know, stealing cars, shooting everyone he suspects of being a baddie, unbothered with due process or the possibility that he’s murdering innocent people. Yes, of course Jack Reacher is bad news, but we all love him, right? This is that. This is just like that.

But this is not only that. Because shortly after Nora arrives at the Regent Hotel, a heavy snowfall paralyses Birmingham, trains are cancelled, and no one can get anywhere easily except on foot (well—there is one other exception, but I won’t spoil that). So when guests and staff start disappearing, and people begin reporting strange creatures appearing in their rooms, the narrative shifts from a psychological, personal narrative about Nora’s plans for her future into something that much more resembles a monster flick—a monster flick which turns out to be intimately connected with all sorts of gruesome details about Nora’s past. Don’t worry, though. Oddly, this book is not in the slightest bit scary, because, of all the people in this story, Nora herself is an extremely competent protagonist, and is well equipped to take care of the bloody business that presents itself. Her solution ends up being not entirely unexpected, but—if you paid attention to the first half of the book and correctly forgot all preconceived notions of virtue and rightness and healthy relationships—it is no less bloodily satisfying.

Well, for me at least. People on Storygraph were not entirely prepared, and rated it accordingly. But not I! And now, dear reader, whom I hope I have prepared, not you, either. Taken on its own terms, this book is macabre and gruesome and psychologically rich and chewy and not the slightest bit healthy. A flourless chocolate cake, with a garnish of fresh blood.

Nerd coefficient: 8/10, well worth your time and attention.

Highlights:

  • Art deco setting
  • Psychoanalysis
  • Cryptids
  • Cannibalism

Reference: Mascarenhas, Kate. Hokey Pokey [Head of Zeus, 2022].

CLARA COHEN lives in Scotland in a creaky old building with pipes for gas lighting still lurking under her floorboards. She is an experimental linguist by profession, and calligrapher and Islamic geometric artist by vocation. During figure skating season she does blather on a bit about figure skating. She is on Mastodon at wandering.shop/@ergative or on Bluesky at https://bsky.app/profile/ergative-abs.bsky.social.