Friday, November 20, 2026

Film Review: Godzilla Minus Zero

First feel fear, and then think about the use of fear

I’m going to be upfront about the fact that I’m not a longtime Godzilla fan; I went to see Godzilla Minus One for the alternate history aspect, and was pleasantly surprised (and terrified) by the King of the Monsters. I’ve only seen a few Godzilla films and have been procrastinating on an actual watch of the whole series for far too long (yes, I’ve seen the original). So my review of this latest film, Godzilla Minus Zero, is not a review from someone who loved this gigantic death lizard as a child, but someone who has come to appreciate it as an adult.

And when I saw Ghidorah in his full, terrifying glory, using wrecked houses as shrapnel, I couldn’t stop saying “HOLY SHIT” over and over again. I hope I didn’t bother anyone else in the theater. Having watched the original film, I am willing to say that Godzilla as a series has unambiguously benefited from modern CGI in a way that other franchises haven’t. Many would agree that Star Wars lost something with CGI spaceships and walkers that don’t have the physicality of the models used in the original trilogy. Here, though, I must confess that I find this modern CGI Godzilla, and Ghidorah, to be simply so much more viscerally terrifying than what is obviously Haruo Nakajima in a suit. Call me a kid, call me spoiled, call me a noob or a LARPer or what have you, but that is how I find myself responding.

It is that sense of viscerality where Godzilla Minus Zero really shines. Maybe I just was in a good theater, but the sound design in particular stands out as a way of shoving you into the back of your seat as you behold behemoths that dwarf you and feel that size difference in your bones. Every roar terrifies you; I fear this may not be replicable on home video, as the volume combined with the particular way movie theaters arrange their speakers does a lot to sell the experience.

(From this point on I’m going to spoil this movie because the themes are too meaty to not do so. Prospective moviegoers, be warned.)

But it’s not only the monsters that are visceral. The human reaction to this madness is likewise visceral, as is the depiction of the consequences of violence. This is the first Godzilla movie to be rated R in the United States (for non-Americans: that rating bars entry to anyone under 17 without an adult present, and is the highest rating in common usage), and it earns that not through any depiction of the mauling of human life, but rather the consequences of the mauling in scenes set in hospitals after the monsters have left their stomping grounds. There is blood. There is gore. There is the anguished screaming from the chest, from the gut, that erupts from the mouths of people who would rather be dead. There are the charred corpses in the rubble that are the end result of the atomic bomb that sent Murakami into a lust for revenge that could end only in blood.

Godzilla Minus One concerned itself with the question of when it is just to sacrifice your life for something. This is a pressing question, particularly when concerning Imperial Japan; this was the age of the kamikaze, of young men who were ordered to yell “Banzai!” before they rammed their plane into an American carrier or battleship. This was also the age of the families who, cognizant of the fact that only unmarried, childless men could become kamikaze pilots, would drown their children in bathtubs before the wife killed herself so that the husband could give his life for a country that was obviously losing a war. It was that willingness to sacrifice beyond all reason that made Dr. Noda’s resolve to lose no Japanese lives in fending off the predations of Godzilla to be so powerful, so moral.

Godzilla Minus Zero, on the other hand, is set some years after the end of the war, and is concerned with questions befitting that distance: when is it justified to seek revenge? When is it justified to seek an eye for an eye, and at what point does that inevitably leave the whole world blind? This film sees that violence begets violence, creating a spiral of hatred and murder that only creates more of the same.

To be more specific, I’m going to draw in some heterodox mass atrocity theory, which I know sounds strange but is the most coherent way I’ve gotten to making sense of this film’s moral core. In 2021, Australian scholar A. Dirk Moses released a book called The Problems of Genocide, in which he argues that genocide, as a legal concept, is fatally flawed due to the political considerations of the people who enshrined it in international law. There’s a lot of fine detail that he goes into, but his core insight, and the most relevant for our purposes, is this: every single act of mass murder comes out of a desire for safety. When you get it in your head that a certain group of people is completely and utterly intent on destroying or oppressing you, there is a clear logic of decision-making that ends in a willingness to wipe every single member of that group off the face of the Earth. Moses then goes on to argue that the ultimate Crime of Crimes in international law should be what he refers to as “permanent security,” a program of being sure that a targeted group of people could never threaten you again—and the way of being sure is through mass murder.

This is a theme discussed and depicted quite explicitly in this film. Japan went to war out of a desire for resource autarky, so that no outside power could threaten it ever again. America responded to this with napalm bombs specifically designed to cause firestorms from burning the wooden buildings common in Japan, so that a militarist Japan could never be a threat to anyone. Japan responded with kamikazes out of fear that the Americans would destroy everything it stood for, and hardline military officers attempted a coup to be sure that its own people would fight to the death. America then, of course, unleashed the power of the sun on Hiroshima and Nagasaki to end the war, with the nice bonus of demonstrating American technological prowess to the Soviets. Godzilla then came rampaging through Tokyo out of a desire to destroy whatever hurt it with the atomic explosions. Japan remilitarized to fight this threat, and America did not help them out of fear of a war with the Soviets. And now, in this film, there are attempts to turn Godzilla into a weapon of war out of fear of the next war (the war after that, of course, would be fought with sticks and stones).

One clear example is Murakami, the Hiroshima survivor who lost everyone he loved and then wishes to use Godzilla to punish America for what it did to him. The film is understanding of that impulse, but unequivocally condemns it. Japan, and the world, have suffered enough. This is likewise the reason why Kōichi and Noriko and Murakami all destroy the plans for how they used Noriko’s mutation to draw Godzilla in, to prevent governments from using him to take even more lives. They know, and the movie absolutely knows, that there is a point when hypothetical concerns for safety must give way to the recognition that violence begets violence. It is a risk, it is always a risk, but at some point there must be a choice to stop, or the whole world will go blind.

Even the film’s ending is concerned with this question. Kōichi and Noriko, after destroying the plans, intend to live a life on the run from the governments of America and Japan. They knew that that decision, however moral, would render them fugitives, and they were prepared to sacrifice everything, including the love and presence of their adopted daughter Akiko. They show up to her daycare to say goodbye, but she breaks down crying, and so do they, and they eventually choose to take her along for their journey. They had chosen to abandon her for her safety, but ultimately take her out of love. They realize that they’re at the point where safety is not the only concern, and choose accordingly. That’s what makes the scene so powerful.

What I do wish, though, was that this film, and the last, were a bit more courageous in naming one particular segment of the victims of this killing. Godzilla and Ghidorah are framed as extensions of World War II, and Imperial Japan is rightly castigated as having ultimately brought havoc and death upon the Japanese people. However, the other countries that were victims of the “Co-Prosperity Sphere” are never mentioned, not China nor Korea nor the Philippines nor Indonesia nor any others. This is minor and pedantic, yes, but as a Filipino-American whose great-grandfather was a resistance fighter and whose grandparents lived through the occupation, a part of me is peeved when Japanese media make this particular omission.

Another minor nitpick: something about the way the English dialogue was written for the American characters felt oh so slightly off. It didn’t quite have the cadence of natural American English. This is ultimately insignificant, and overall I think the movie portrayed the American occupation forces rather well, but it was noticeable. It was certainly better than the Korean film Operation Chromite, which had bizarre dialogues for American characters and a far too cuddly Douglas MacArthur to boot.

Godzilla Minus Zero has the courage to say that safety cannot be used to justify everything. We live in a world where safety is the major justification for all sorts of horrors that I don’t need to mention. It delivers that message in the interesting package of pure, unbridled terror. You are put in a situation where you viscerally understand—indeed, your nervous system viscerally understands—why people would want a state of permanent security, to go on a permanent war footing in hopes of ending somebody forever. But the film has the chutzpah to tell you that that instinct is not necessarily a good one, nor necessarily a humane one.


POSTED BY: Alex Wallace, alternate history buff who reads more than is healthy.