A cozy dystopia that really misses the mark
The Infinite Sadness of Small Appliances by Glenn Dixon has a fairly adorable premise (even if “sadness” in the title makes one wonder if it will turn dark): a young, sentient Roomba tries to save her humans from a dark technological overlord. There have been several recent popular explorations of small sentient appliances or robots, such as Adrian Tchaikovsky’s Service Model (2024), Annalee Newitz’s Automatic Noodle (2025), and Suzanne Palmer’s Ode to the Half-Broken (2026). The Newitz and the Tchaikovsky were even both finalists for the Hugo (and it’s too early to know if Palmer’s will be a finalist, but I’m sure it will be nominated!). But this newest take on small sentient appliances misses the mark: it lacks fairly basic understandings of technology, which means it cannot think through how a machine brain might be different from a human one. Further, and even more damning, the overarching lesson of the book seems to be more about preserving stuff than relationships.
I wanted to like this book. I am absolutely the target audience for this book! It’s by a Canadian author, I found it on a Canada Broadcasting Company (CBC) listicle recommending books, and I am generally down for what is sometimes disparagingly called “cozy dystopia.” But this book left me in the incredibly weird position of wanting to defend big surveillance technology?
Set in a near but undefined future, the story follows the self-named “Scout,” a Roomba-style vacuum that works for an older couple named Edie and Harold. Harold is a retired high school English teacher obsessed with finding and sometimes restoring first editions of classic 20th century novels (such as To Kill a Mockingbird, from which Scout took her name; The Alchemist; and C.S. Lewis’s Narnia chronicles). Edie is a retired pianist and piano teacher dying from cancer. [This part will definitely remind you of the beginning of the movie Up.]
In the house with Scout there are several other appliances with various levels of sentience: we meet Clock, Refrigerator, Thermostat, and Auto. Watch, who lives embodied in a smart watch on Harold’s wrist, connects the team with The Grid, which monitors the house and its inhabitants.
The first half of the book focuses on Scout’s journey of self-discovery, which largely seems to be about Scout learning to appreciate piano music and 20th-century literature. After Edie’s death, we mostly lose track of Scout until she can provide a deus ex machina for the plot. Instead, we’re introduced to Kate, Harold and Edie’s estranged daughter, who returns to the home to help Harold downsize and prepare to move.
With these characters, we are set up for a clear dystopia: an all-controlling, all-watching Grid that takes away human freedom. But, in actuality, The Grid doesn’t seem that all-powerful. It can literally be thwarted by stepping halfway outside the garage so it can’t “hear” you in the house. It can become so “busy” with other things in the house that Scout has more than two minutes of time to hack into something she’s not supposed to be listening to. There are dissidents who live “off the grid” that The Grid cannot seem to thwart despite the fact that they’re often just walking around in neighbourhoods? In the end, the final “hack” to deceive The Grid has at least half a dozen ways that it would be spotted immediately by any even moderately effective AI.
I don’t expect every author who writes about technology to be a programmer (and I am not one!), but I felt like many of the basic misses related to computers and how they work should have been evident to anyone who even sometimes reads science fiction with AI or machine minds. Scout, our vacuum-protagonist, does not read as a machine or computer. All of the appliance characters could have been replaced with human servants without making any difference to the book. (And, for a more charitable analysis, perhaps that’s the point? We are making all powerful AIs and robots because what we fundamentally want is the ability to have slaves.)
I was also disappointed about the overall lesson of the book. All the conflict over The Grid has to do with Harold and his stuff. He only notices that he’s, apparently, living in an AI-controlled dystopia when he may be forced to move into a smaller home. He didn’t notice when his daughter was taken away and not allowed to visit for years. He didn’t notice when a neighbour boy and a former student of Edie’s, Adrian, seemed to be living some kind of precarious existence because they’re not registered citizens and therefore not eligible for The Grid’s UBI. He only notices when The Grid wants to take Edie’s piano so he can be moved into a smaller home.
The Grid’s evil mission appears to be the densification of cities. It wants Harold to move into a smaller house because he’s now an older man living alone. And, to be honest, when Harold falls down the stairs of his large single-family home and breaks his hip, you kind of think The Grid has a point?
I live in the very expensive city of Vancouver, British Columbia, where there is a constant push and pull between some older people who bought single-family homes in the 70s and 80s when they were inexpensive and don’t want to pay taxes on what has become their multimillion dollar assets, don’t want to downsize, and oppose even gentle efforts at neighbourhood densification. Reading this book made me wonder if one of them had written it.
While I, in general, definitely oppose Big Technology and do not want to live in a surveillance state, the goals of The Grid in this book seemed so Left-coded that I felt like I was being trolled: The Grid gives almost everyone UBI; they’re trying to move people into the city centre; they want to preserve human art to understand it!
The neighbour character, Adrian, and his mother offer a small hint of what it might be like to live as someone in this Grid-controlled city who is undocumented in some way. We are told that they have some problems with money and *gasp* are forced to live in a basement suite. But it’s left at that, and we get no resolution to their plot. (Also, as a Vancouverite, almost everyone I know has lived in a basement suite at some point. It’s fine!) The book barely explores these characters. I thought the obvious community-oriented answer to Harold and Kate trying to find a way for him to stay in his home was for him to welcome Adrian and his mom into their house! But no.
In the end (and I am going to totally spoil the book here), Scout is able to hack into The Grid to eliminate Edie’s death date, theoretically making The Grid think that Harold is not living in the house alone. Kate makes contact with dissidents who help her flee to a community living off the grid in the woods. So, in a supposedly happy ending here, Harold is getting to keep living in a Grid-controlled city, alone in a giant house while, presumably, not able to communicate at all with his daughter? Hooray!
While I often enjoy the small scale of cozy dystopias, The Infinite Sadness of Small Appliances really didn’t work for me. The robots were just people with robot faces, and the overall lesson focused too much on materialism at the expense of relationships. Skip this one and go read Murderbot. It's less cozy, but a lot better.
Highlights:
- Very weak “all-powerful” Grid bent on world domination
- Sweet old couple characters that will remind you a bit of Up
- The writing about technology will irritate any moderately tech-savvy readers
Nerd Coefficient: 3/10, “very little good I can say about this.”
Reference: Dixon, Glenn. The Infinite Sadness of Small Appliances [Atria Books, 2026].
POSTED BY: Christine D. Baker, historian and lover of SFF and mysteries. You can find her also writing reviews at Ancillary Review of Books or podcasting about classic scifi/fantasy at Hugo History. Come chat books with her on Bluesky @klaxoncomms.com.
