Thursday, November 12, 2026

Anime Review: Though I Am an Inept Villainess: Cour One

Magic, vengeance, palace drama, and humor 


Sometimes life seems better on the other side. One person is showered with affection and praise while another drowns in cruelty and bitterness. But what is life really like for the person of whom you are jealous? And how do you navigate these deep thoughts while also dealing with a murder plot and lots of palace intrigue. It’s been a long wait for the return of The Apothecary Diaries. In the meantime, an anime with a very similar historical setting but much lighter tone has arrived to fill the gap. Though I Am An Inept Villainess, is based on a popular light novel series and tells the story of two women, one kind, one bitter, who are each suffering in different ways. But things get complicated when a forbidden spell causes them to switch bodies with unexpected results. The story has the familiar vibes of The Goose Girl fairy tale, but with an optimistic, humorous, and ironic take on life switching.

Though I Am An Inept Villainess, is set in a magical, ancient China-like setting where the imperial palace houses numerous consorts, concubines, and selected maidens from noble families who are there for the emperor and his family. Reirin is a beautiful and kind maiden from the Kou clan. Her beauty and sweet personality make her a favorite of the handsome young crown prince Gyoumei. Her assigned villa is lavish, her attendants fawn over her, and she is referred to as the court’s beautiful “butterfly”. Meanwhile Keigetsu is the designated maiden of the Shu clan. She is despised and mistreated because the other maidens and consorts deem her unworthy, despite the fact that she is related to the respected, polite and reserved noble consort, Shu Gabi. The bullying Keigetsu suffers in the palace fuels her anger causing her to be rude and bitter, which further ostracizes her. In frustration, Keigetsu uses illegal magic to swap bodies with the beautiful Reirin while attempting to injure her in front of a crowd of court ladies and the crown prince. Reirin’s body is saved with Keigetsu in possession of it. Meanwhile Reirin is trapped in Keigetsu’s body and sentenced to a harsh trial for attempting to hurt Reirin. Keigetsu is initially thrilled to be pampered and fawned over but she soon discovers that Reirin’s body is actually sick and frail and in constant pain, despite her sunny disposition. Reirin, on the other hand, is subjected to hatred and cruelty as a consequence of being trapped in Keigetsu’s body, and the curse prevents her from telling anyone the truth about the body swap. But instead of being despondent, Reirin is thrilled to have a healthy body and to be able to eat what she wants and to be physically active. Even when she is demoted to a run down, damaged villa, she eagerly accepts it and works hard to patch it up and dig a vegetable garden to grow her own food. In Keigetsu’s body she only has one surly attendant, Leelee, who openly despises her and even tries to hurt her due to the original Keigetsu’s mistreatment of her. But Reirin’s persistent natural cheerfulness and Keigetsu’s inevitable grouchiness eventually cause those close to them to notice that something isn’t right with the two maidens. Beyond that, a larger scheme of palace intrigue and a revenge murder plot force the two women to work together to solve the larger mystery.

While the series has many overlapping elements with The Apothecary Diaries, including court intrigue, murder mysteries, and an imperial harem setting, Though I Am An Inept Villainess has a much lighter tone. The earlier episodes are particularly humorous with Reirin’s relentless optimism leaving everyone perplexed and the audience amused. The series is almost entirely female focused with most of the intrigue happening among the women. The serious and earnest crown prince Gyumei is aided in his oversight of the palace by his sharp and cynical younger half-brother Shin-U. The two are the only men who appear regularly and a brief flashback offers some interesting insight into the power imbalance in their relationship. The girl-power vibe is ironic in such a setting. The shows does a nice job of telling parallel tales of jealousy, sisterhood, revenge, and reconciliation among different generations in the imperial household. Those themes resonate as Reirin and Keigetsu navigate their response to different types of trauma as well as the relentless pressure of societal expectations.

Overall, Though I Am An Inept Villainess delivers lighthearted storytelling with humor and just enough intrigue and personality drama to keep viewers hooked. While not as perfectly crafted as The Apothecary Diaries, the series offers solid entertainment and unexpectedly complex characters in an unexpectedly complicated world.

--

The Math

Nerd Coefficient: 7/10

Highlights:
  • Fantasy fairy tale vibes
  • Light comedy and cuteness
  • Sweet messaging
POSTED BY: Ann Michelle Harris – Multitasking, fiction writing Trekkie currently dreaming of her next beach vacation.